Randy Jacksons Says Goodbye Dawg!

Entertainment, Randy Jacksn, American Idol    

by Melissa Stansfeld


The gist

After 12 seasons as a judge on American Idol, Randy Jackson has ann...
show more
After 12 seasons as a judge on American Idol, Randy Jackson has announced that he is leaving AI. <br><br>How would you rate his overall performance as an AI judge?
show less

  Opinion Poll


   650 Points on the line.

   33 joined this poll.     

   0 Days Remaining.

   22 Comments.




This poll has ended.
Winner: Awesome

58% of the group voted correctly.

Awesome


58%
Just OK


30%
Should Have Been Replaced Seasons Ago


12%

Comments

  • 54.74%

    Top Comment: Charles Johnson voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    He is an awesome judge! i salute yo dawg fo that! ur d man!


  • 54.01%

    Top Comment: Titus Fitz voted for Should Have Been Replaced Seasons Ago about 6 years ago.

    No offense dawg, but Randy should have exited the stage a while back right after Simon. He's just too in the middle and too reasonable. They tried to give him the contrast of extremes with other judges, but what they needed to do was put someone with a strong personality like Simon on there in place of Randy because eventually the other judges become vanilla.


  • 58.67%

    Top Comment: DJ Franz voted for Should Have Been Replaced Seasons Ago about 6 years ago.

    he should've go with Simon...


  • 38.61%

    Steven Shirey about 6 years ago.

    i told yall, he's awesome!


  • 53.33%

    Joshua Townsend about 6 years ago.

    randy jackson was really an awesome judge in AI, now, there is no one to shout the word "dawg" in there


  • 57.69%

    William Brown about 6 years ago.

    no one's gonna miss him


  • 44.9%

    Carl Emmanuel voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    just ok, he just did his job and there's nothing special with that


  • 62.96%

    Garrett Hurtado voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    he's passionate and he gives a good critique everytime he judges, he's awesome bro


  • 59.26%

    Shark Man voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    if he did this earlier, well, it would be awesome.


  • 87.8%

    Lucy Kirksen voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    After 12 seasons ? and now he's leaving ? how sad :'(


  • 50.67%

    Milford Perez voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    just ok.. he only did what he should do..


  • 45.45%

    Mabel Shelton voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    naaaaah, just ok.. well, why not replace all the judges with new ones


  • 54.74%

    Charles Johnson voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    that would be better, the judges arent as good as Simon and Randy..


  • 45.28%

    Bruce Manley voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    well, i find him dumb specially when he salutes and praises and claps with whoever the performer is, his gestures are weird haha


  • 58.49%

    Bevis Anderson voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    he is the best judge eva in AI! yo dawg! we salute!


  • 54.12%

    Ricardo Hearn voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    Randy as a judge is awesome, AI wouldnt be complete if there's no one shouting DAWG! haha


  • 58.67%

    DJ Franz voted for Should Have Been Replaced Seasons Ago about 6 years ago.

    he should've go with Simon...


  • 62.96%

    Garrett Hurtado voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    AI would be different if there's no one to shout the word "DAWG" in the judge panel


  • 78.57%

    James La Rosa voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    No one can replace Randy Jackson, Thank you Dawg for being part of AI


  • 33.33%

    Albert Neace voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    just okay, Nicki's a better judge compared to him


  • 54.01%

    Titus Fitz voted for Should Have Been Replaced Seasons Ago about 6 years ago.

    No offense dawg, but Randy should have exited the stage a while back right after Simon. He's just too in the middle and too reasonable. They tried to give him the contrast of extremes with other judges, but what they needed to do was put someone with a strong personality like Simon on there in place of Randy because eventually the other judges become vanilla.


  • 49.02%

    Austin Stewart voted for Just OK about 6 years ago.

    i like it when u say strong personality lol, AI should look for another mean judge just like Simon


  • 56.52%

    Melissa Stansfeld voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    It's going to be weird without Randy there. But maybe that's what they're counting on. A fresh new feel to the show. Cause honestly, it's just not the same and it hasn't been since Simon left. I just wonder who can fill the slot?


  • 54.74%

    Charles Johnson voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    He is an awesome judge! i salute yo dawg fo that! ur d man!


  • 52.3%

    Julio Polio voted for Awesome about 6 years ago.

    AI won't be the same, dawg!


Related Polls


  • Jet Li vs Jackie Chan
    147     15     1169
      

  • Is Donald Trump the coolest candidate ever?
    3     1     0
      

  • Who's Worse: Hannity vs O'Reilly
    4     1     30